Cleveland Traditional Pierogi Flavors: A Taste of Slavic Village

In Cleveland, pierogi aren’t just food—they are a cultural institution. From family holidays to Friday fish frys, these "pillowy pockets" of dough are woven into the fabric of our city’s history.

While new fusion flavors are popping up everywhere, there is something irreplaceable about the classics. At Janka Pierogis, we have been keeping the tradition alive in the heart of Slavic Village since 1951. We stick to the authentic Polish recipes passed down through the Krusinski family, ensuring every bite tastes just like it did generations ago.

If you are looking to fill your freezer with authentic Cleveland soul food, here are the traditional flavors we craft by hand every day.

1. Potato & Cheese (The Cleveland Classic)

If there were an official food of Cleveland, this might be it. Our Potato & Cheese Pierogi are the gold standard. We use a creamy blend of mashed potatoes and cheese (often American cheese for that perfect melt) wrapped in our tender, homemade dough. They are perfect boiled with a little butter or pan-fried until golden and crispy with onions.

2. Sauerkraut

For those who love the tangy, savory side of Polish cuisine, Sauerkraut Pierogi are a must. We fill ours with traditional sauerkraut that packs a flavorful punch. It’s a staple for holiday dinners (Wigilia) but delicious enough to eat year-round. Many locals swear by pairing these with kielbasa for the ultimate comfort meal.

3. Sweet Cheese (Cottage Cheese)

A true Polish delicacy that is harder to find in standard grocery stores is the Sweet Cheese Pierogi. Filled with a sweetened cottage cheese or farmer’s cheese blend, these offer a lighter, creamy taste that pairs beautifully with a dollop of sour cream or a dusting of sugar. If you haven't tried this style, you are missing out on a huge part of the pierogi tradition.

4. Fruit Flavors (Apple)

Pierogi for dessert? Absolutely. Fruit-filled pierogi are a beloved summer treat in Poland and a nostalgic favorite here in Cleveland.

Apple: Sweet, spiced, and comforting.

• Fry in melted butter and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar or a dollop of sweetened cream.

  
  

Taste the Tradition at Krusinski’s Market

We don't just sell pierogi; we make them right here in Cleveland using local ingredients and time-honored techniques. Whether you grew up in Slavic Village or are just discovering these flavors, we invite you to taste the difference that handmade quality makes.

Ready to stock up? You can order our authentic pierogi online for local pickup or shipping! 👉 Shop All Janka Pierogi Flavors Here

Visit Us: Krusinski’s Market 6300 Heisley Ave, Cleveland, OH 44105